Robert Kugel's Analyst Perspectives

Optimizing Subscription Management for Finance and Accounting

Posted by Robert Kugel on Jan 24, 2023 3:00:00 AM

The subscription and recurring revenue business models became a significant part of the economy this century with the advent of streaming services for entertainment and software as a service. They have grown in popularity because they enhance customer lifetime value by evolving what had previously been a one-time-sale relationship into a delivery of ongoing services which can create a more loyal customer relationship as well as provide a regular, more predictable revenue stream. I recommend that corporations that have adopted or are planning to adopt either of these business models take a continuous accounting approach to managing their record keeping. Ventana Research asserts that by 2026, one-half of subscription organizations will use continuous accounting to remove constraints limiting sales and marketing flexibility, streamline back-office processes, shorten the accounting close and improve customer satisfaction.

Subscriptions are a well-established business model, but what has historically been a relatively simple accounting process for newspapers, magazines and other periodicals (straight-line amortization of the Ventana_Research_2023_Assertion_ERP_Sub_Org_ContAcc_50_Sup-front cash payment over the subscription term) now presents corporations with challenges because today these business arrangements can be more complex. For example, their scope can change frequently as the number of users of the service increase or decrease, or charges can vary seasonally, or there may be some consumption element that varies period to period. In addition, today’s revenue recognition standards have made the accounting more complicated because each of the components of a given contract may require different accounting treatments. The challenge can be even greater for companies that have adopted a hybrid approach that combines a one-time product sale with an ongoing set of services or consumables because their existing financial management system may not easily accommodate this type of business model or may require extensive modifications to support subscriptions.

Continuous accounting enables companies to achieve four main objectives that improve performance in handling subscription or recurring revenue arrangements. First, managing the flow of business and financial data Ventana_Research_Benchmark_Research_Office_of_Finance_19_17_Fast _Closers_Have_Timely_Information_20220106in a straight-through, end-to-end process ensures data integrity which, by guaranteeing accuracy, cuts accounting workloads by eliminating the need for checks and reconciliations. Data accuracy issues, often overlooked at a systemic level, cause unnecessary workloads for accountants. A lack of assured integrity forces all billing information to be checked because not reconciling data almost guarantees there will be errors that either annoy customers because they are overcharged or create revenue leakage when they are underbilled. Moreover, as data moves from the front office to the back office, systems must maintain a consistent record of the nature of each revenue element to ensure accurate revenue recognition treatment to minimize workloads, guarantee compliance and reduce potential audit issues.

Second, straight-through processing eliminates period-end bottlenecks because data doesn’t need to be reconciled all at once, and transactions can be reviewed whenever necessary, at any time. What has been regarded as a given set of monthly, quarterly and annual routines is not set in stone but is rooted in centuries-old limitations imposed by paper-based systems and manual calculations. Today’s business applications can continuously process data end to end so work schedules can be restructured to better distribute workloads to eliminate the period-end “crunch” time and increase operational efficiency. This enables companies to close their books sooner, which promotes agility in operations. Our Office of Finance Benchmark Research finds that 62% of companies that close within six business days have timely information compared to 39% that take longer.

Third, reporting and responsiveness can be improved because technology provides executives and managers the ability to track performance and progress toward objectives continuously, using dashboards vr_finance_analytics_09_Preparing_Data_Takes_the_Most_Time_20220106tailored to their specific needs and designed to accelerate decision-making. Moreover, working from a single authoritative source of data eliminates the need for financial and business analysts to spend time on data preparation and reconciliation, enabling them to shorten cycles and broaden the scope of their analyses. Our Next-Generation Finance Analytics Benchmark Research finds that analysts typically spend the biggest share of their time (68%) on data-related tasks, such as assembling and transforming data, rather than doing what they are trained to do: analyze.

And fourth, a lack of data integrity and the resulting need for checks and reconciliations before invoicing and billing often has the underestimated impact of limiting the flexibility of sales and marketing as they create and, crucially, change offers and terms. To make accounting workloads manageable, companies either try to limit the complexity and variability of the offers or they put up with some degree of inaccuracy in billing. However, it is possible for both the front office and back office to get what they need when the organization deploys a billing system that delivers data integrity using straight-through transaction processing. Rather than always finding themselves behind the curve, sales and marketing can respond to better- or worse-than-expected results, even during the middle of a month, by modifying an offer or increasing some incentive without having an impact on back-office workloads.

Corporations with a subscription or recurring revenue business model should adopt a continuous accounting approach to manage these transactions. Technology has made it possible to not only remove operational constraints that once limited sales and marketing flexibility but also to streamline back-office processes, shorten the accounting close and improve customer satisfaction. Organizations that were established around subscriptions or a recurring revenue arrangement with customers very likely have a financial management system that is designed to support this model. However, those product companies that have adopted a hybrid approach or are now considering it must assess whether their existing system can easily support subscriptions and a continuous accounting approach. I recommend that they consider using dedicated subscription management software that also automates revenue recognition processes. This sort of system operates in parallel with the main financial management application, creating a sub-ledger that easily meshes with existing accounting methods. They may find that this approach is faster, easier and has a lower total cost of ownership than modifying their existing software.


Robert Kugel

Topics: Office of Finance, Financial Performance Management, ERP and Continuous Accounting, digital finance

Robert Kugel

Written by Robert Kugel

Rob heads up the CFO and business research focusing on the intersection of information technology with the finance organization and business. The financial performance management (FPM) research agenda includes the application of IT to financial process optimization and collaborative systems; control systems and analytics; and advanced budgeting and planning. Prior to joining Ventana Research he was an equity research analyst at several firms including First Albany Corporation, Morgan Stanley, and Drexel Burnham, and a consultant with McKinsey and Company. Rob was an Institutional Investor All-American Team member and on the Wall Street Journal All-Star list. Rob has experience in aerospace and defense, banking, manufacturing and retail and consumer services. Rob earned his BA in Economics/Finance at Hampshire College, an MBA in Finance/Accounting at Columbia University, and is a CFA charter holder.